History of the Brampton Excelsiors

The history of the Brampton Excelsiors is long and storied. They first started playing in 1871, organized by the second Master of Brampton High School George M. Lee. The story goes that he was inspired to name the team “Excelsiors” after the title of a poem by Henry W. Longfellow. In 1883, the team began formal Provincial league play and established the Brampton Excelsiors Lacrosse Club.

1914 Brampton Excelsiors
The 1914 Brampton Excelsiors

In 1926 the New Westminster Salmonbellies donated the Mann Cup (which had previously been a challenge trophy) to the CLA and it became the National Championship of senior lacrosse. Only four years later, in 1930, the Excelsiors won their first title. The same year saw a Jr. A Provincial championship as well as the Intermediates’ fifth championship title. The following year, the Excelsiors became the final team to win the Mann Cup playing under the rules of field lacrosse. In 1932 the CLA adopted box lacrosse rules and Brampton would not make the finals again for the next decade. The rest of the 1930’s saw lacrosse become synonymous with Brampton. Playing out of the bowl at Rosalea Park, the Excelsiors would regularly draw crowds in the thousands, a significant portion of the town’s population at the time.

1931 Brampton Excelsiors, Mann Cup Champions
The 1931 National Champion Brampton Excelsiors. The CLA adopted the rules of box lacrosse the following year.

In the 40’s Brampton saw the Mann Cup return again when the team, as the Mimico-Brampton combines, captured their third Mann Cup in 1942. This would be the last one they hoisted for nearly four decades, missing out on another back-to-back championship when they lost to the Salmonbellies in the finals the following year. In 1943 the Brampton Minor Lacrosse Association was founded and formally entered the Ontario Minor Lacrosse Association in 1946. One of the key figures in the early history of the BMLA was lacrosse legend George “Mush” Thompson. The Mush Thompson award is now presented annually by the BELC to a member of the Brampton lacrosse community demonstrating outstanding dedication to the sport.

Though the championship drought at the senior level continued in the 50’s, the decade did see the Jr. A Excelsiors dominate Canadian lacrosse. In 1952 they brought home their first Minto Cup. They again made it to the finals in 1956 but lost to the Mt. Pleasant Legionnaires before winning the cup again the next three straight years. In 1959 future Lacrosse and NHL legend John McCauley, at just fourteen years old, set a CLA record for the youngest player to play on a National Championship team.

The Minto Cup
The Minto Cup, donated in 1901 by Lord Minto has be the Canadian Jr. A trophy since 1937

The next few decades saw the teams reach the National Finals a few times, but did not manage to bring home another championship above the minor level until the Majors won their fourth Mann Cup in 1980 taking the series 4-1 over New Westminster. After that the team would go on to win another six Cups including back-to-back victories in 1992-93 and 2008-09 (along side wins in 1998, 2002 an 2011), and making it to the National finals an additional four times. Another Minto Cup remains Elusive for the Jr. A Excelsiors though they did reached the finals 1962, 1976, 1994, 2009 and 2018.

Brampton Excelsior Dan Teat holding the Mann Cup
Then Captain, current Head coach of the Major Excelsiors, as well as ELLA President and founding member Dan Teat holding the Mann Cup in 2009

In 2018 it was announced by the BELC, amid declining attendance and financial difficulties, that the team had been sold to owner of Detroit-based ‘Bug Juice’, Joe Norton. For the first time in the history of the Brampton Excelsiors, the team was no community owned. During his time operating the team Norton received heavy criticism for his disregard of the team’s history as well as the fans and for heavily promoting Bug Juice, which has not been approved for sale in Ontario.

On November 18, 2020 it was announced by Norton that he planned to relocate the team to Owen Sound, Ontario in what would be the team’s 150th year. This received immediate backlash from Excelsiors supporters across the lacrosse community. The integrity of the team’s sale, Joe Norton and the members of the BELC Executive Committee were all quickly called into question. Weeks of fighting on social media eventually led to a petition calling on the OLA to dissolve the BELC Committee. In turn this eventually lead to the formation of the ELLA. In another decision under a lot of scrutiny the OLA Board of Governors approved the sale and move of the team. This vote however was rescinded following an appeal by members of ELLA. After soliciting a legal opinion from the Association’s lawyers, the OLA board of directors voted to not approve or recognize the sale of the Brampton Excelsiors, and to not sanction the competition of an Owen Sound team in the MSL, based on a complete lack of evidence presented to prove the legality of the sale. The franchise certificate of the Brampton Excelsiors remains the property of the BELC. Despite this ruling, MSL commissioner Doug Luey has continued the narrative that the Excelsiors will be Owen Sound going forward. ELLA has continued to fight back against this and pressure the OLA to enforce their ruling.

Following news and details of this ruling reaching them, the members of the BELC called and held a special general meeting seeking answers and to hold the Executives responsible. At this meeting a special resolution was passed to dismiss the sitting directors and instill an interim board with the directive to organize a constitutional AGM. In the following months members of the former executive continued to insist on their right to the positions, ignoring the voices of the membership. They cited on multiple occasions a confidential memo addressed to the OLA board of directors stating the presidency of Ziggy Musial would be recognized at that time. It was noted that this memo was long out of date and a full record of the actions taken by the BELC membership had since been submitted to the board for review. Through this, the interim board followed their directive, holding a formal AGM in early December, at which a duly elected board of directors was voted in led by ELLA’s Glenn McClelland as club President. The former group continues to state their claim against the members and the OLA has yet to make any statement on the issue. The elected directors have none the less continued to carry out their duties including a formal directive from the members to field a successful Major Excelsiors team in 2022.

The Excelsiors Lacrosse Legacy Association has taken up the duty of fighting to protect all of this. The history of the Brampton Excelsiors is long, amazing and very personal for many people. It should never have been allowed to get thrown away with such little regard. We hope to be adding this this amazing story again in the near future in cooperation with the newly elected BELC Executive.